Frankies Olive Oil: What Frankies 457 Actually Sells
By Yusuf Elsayed, Founder of Sidr & Stone · Last updated 20 November 2026Share
Frankies olive oil is sold by Frankies 457 (Frankies Specialty Foods LLC), the food brand of Brooklyn chefs Frank Falcinelli and Frank Castronovo, named after their restaurant at 457 Court Street. The oils are Sicilian: an Organic EVOO made from Nocellara del Belice and an Everyday Oil blending three Sicilian varieties, both described as grown and harvested in Selinunte and sold as extra virgin. The brand's shop publishes no harvest date, acidity or polyphenol figure. Checked 20 October 2026.
This review reads the brand's own shop and restaurant pages and selected retail listings; we have not tasted a current bottle or seen a laboratory report for it.
The Short Answer
- Frankies 457 is a restaurant name first. The "457" is a street number: 457 Court Street, Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn, home of Frankies 457 Spuntino.
- The founders are Frank Falcinelli and Frank Castronovo. The packaged-goods business trades as Frankies Specialty Foods LLC.
- The oil is Sicilian. The brand describes its olives as grown and harvested in Selinunte, Sicily, and its about page has credited a partnership with the Asaro family.
- There are three oils. An organic extra virgin from Nocellara del Belice, an everyday extra virgin blending Nocellara del Belice, Biancolilla and Cerasuola, and a Calabrian chilli oil, which is a flavoured condiment.
- No chemistry and no harvest date are published online. That is the norm for the category rather than a singular gap.
Frankies 457 Is a Restaurant Group First
The number in the name is an address. Frankies 457 Spuntino sits at 457 Court Street in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn, and the group's restaurant site describes it as "the pioneering Brooklyn restaurant" and as having served its Italian-American cooking there for "nearly two decades". Its own about page credits "its beloved chef-owners, Frank Castronovo and Frank Falcinelli".
The group is now four rooms. Alongside the original are F&F Pizzeria at 459 Court Street, Franks Wine Bar on the same block, and Frankies Nashville, which the site describes as the first restaurant opened outside New York City, in 2023. The packaged-goods business trades separately as Frankies Specialty Foods LLC, and its online shop now calls itself Frankies Olive Oil.
A restaurant brand's authority is real: these are people who have used a lot of olive oil, critically, for a long time. It is a different kind of authority from a grower's, which is why it helps to know who mills the oil.

Who Actually Mills the Oil
The brand's about page has described the oil as "made in partnership with the legendary Asaro family, the first and last word in Sicilian olive oil production", with the olives grown and harvested at Selinunte, on the south-western coast of Sicily, and the process summarised as "harvested, cold-pressed, and packaged in the birthplace of the industry". (The about page did not load its full text when we rechecked on 20 October 2026; the Selinunte origin is still stated on both oil listings.)
So the model is a partnership: a Brooklyn brand, a Sicilian grower-miller, and an oil bottled in Sicily and shipped to the United States. That is an ordinary and often excellent arrangement. It is how many chef and restaurant brands are built, and it puts the fruit and the mill in the same place, which matters most for freshness.
What it does not give you is a single traceable grove. "Selinunte" is a locality, not a field, and the partner's own specifications are not reproduced on the Frankies site. Our piece on single-estate olive oil explains that distinction in general terms.

The Frankies Range and Prices
The range is small and the descriptions name the olive varieties, which tells you the style to expect before you open the bottle. Prices below are from the brand's own online shop, checked on 20 October 2026; retail prices vary.
| Product | What it is | Olives named | Size and price (brand shop, 20 Oct 2026) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Organic EVOO | Extra virgin, described as "a fully organic olive oil" | Nocellara del Belice, grown and harvested in Selinunte | 1L, $36.99 |
| Everyday Oil | Extra virgin, a three-variety blend | Nocellara del Belice, Biancolilla, Cerasuola, grown and harvested in Selinunte | 1L, $36.99 |
| Calabrian Chili Oil | Flavoured condiment, not a plain extra virgin | Four named chillies plus Frankies extra virgin olive oil | 500ml, $24.99 |
Nocellara del Belice is best known as a table olive (the plump bright-green Castelvetrano is the same cultivar), and as an oil it tends towards the green, grassy end with moderate bitterness. Biancolilla is softer and more almondy; Cerasuola is the more assertive of the three. A blend of all three is a deliberately rounded everyday oil. Our piece on Sicilian olive oil covers the island's varieties in full.
The chilli oil is labelled as a condiment, which is the right way round. For where flavoured oils sit relative to plain grades, our guide to what extra virgin olive oil actually is covers the definitions.

What the Label Declares, and What It Leaves Out
| What a buyer wants | Frankies 457 (brand shop, 20 Oct 2026) |
|---|---|
| Country and locality of origin | Published: Selinunte, Sicily |
| Olive variety | Published: named per oil |
| Grade | Published: extra virgin |
| Harvest or crush date | Not published online |
| Free acidity, peroxide value, K232/K270 | Not published online |
| Total polyphenols (mg/kg) | Not published online |
| Organic certifier | "Fully organic" stated; no certifier named in the product description |
On organic status, the product description calls the flagship oil "a fully organic olive oil" but does not name a certifying body. That is most likely a website gap: if the oil is certified, the seal and certifier code will be on the physical bottle, so check there before relying on it.
On dates, the brand's own blog has advised readers to check for a harvest date to ensure freshness, which is sound advice. A harvest date is not shown for the oils on the shop pages, as is usual at this scale, so look for one on the bottle itself.
The organic oil's description calls it "the Greatest Olive Oil in the World". That is the brand's own wording, and no test can settle a superlative of that kind, so we report it rather than repeat it as fact. Some of the brand's blog posts also make general health statements about olive oil; we do not reproduce other companies' health claims.

How to Buy a Chef-Founded Olive Oil Well
With restaurant and chef brands you are buying partly a reputation and partly a liquid. These checks separate the two.
| What to check | Why it matters for a chef brand | Where to find it |
|---|---|---|
| Who actually mills it | Tells you whether the brand grows, commissions or simply labels | The about or story page |
| A named locality, not just a country | "Product of Italy" can cover blended imports; a town is narrower | Product description: Frankies states Selinunte, Sicily |
| The cultivar | Sets the flavour style before you open it | Front or back label |
| A harvest or crush date | The strongest freshness signal | Neck or back label |
| What an award actually says | A medallion is checkable only with competition, year and category named | Product page or bottle |
Beyond that the usual disciplines apply: dark glass or tin, a size you will finish within a season of opening, and somewhere cool and dark to keep it. Our guide to choosing a quality olive oil works through the full checklist, and our guide to the best store-bought olive oil covers the choice at the shelf.
Is Frankies 457 a Good Olive Oil Brand?
Frankies 457 is a credible, open brand: it names the country, the locality, the cultivars and the grade, and its organic oil comes from a single named variety. Both extra virgins are sold in 1L bottles through its own shop and US grocers including Whole Foods Market. What it shares with most of the shelf is the absence of published harvest dates and chemistry, so judge the bottle in hand by its date and taste.
How It Compares with a Single-Estate Oil
Both name their olives: Frankies uses Nocellara del Belice, and ours is mainly Moroccan Picholine and French Picholine, with some Arbequina. Frankies is genuinely ahead on one thing: it describes its flagship as fully organic, while our oil is grown naturally. Where a single-estate oil differs is traceability: one farm we work ourselves, cold-pressed, unfiltered and tested batch by batch.
| Frankies 457 Organic EVOO | Sidr & Stone Marrakech (500ml) | |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Selinunte, Sicily, via a grower partnership; grove not stated | One estate near Marrakech, Morocco, which we farm ourselves |
| Organic status | Described as fully organic | Grown naturally, not certified organic |
| Variety | Nocellara del Belice, named | Mainly Moroccan Picholine and French Picholine, with some Arbequina |
| Filtering | Not stated | Unfiltered |
| Testing | No figures published online | Every batch independently tested |
If a named Sicilian cultivar and a stated organic claim come first for you, Frankies covers them. If you would rather trace your oil to one farm and one batch, our Cold-Pressed Single-Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil - Marrakech (500ml) is made for that.
Why Sidr & Stone
Sidr & Stone makes one olive oil, from one farm we work ourselves, and every bottle can be traced.
- Sidr & Stone's olive oil is single-estate: our own family-owned farm near Marrakech, Morocco, with every step controlled from tree to bottle and no blending across origins.
- Sidr & Stone's olives are grown without pesticides, herbicides or chemical fertilisers.
- Sidr & Stone has every batch independently tested.
- Our olives are picked when the fruit is ready; the product page has this harvest's details.
- Sidr & Stone's oil is cold-pressed.
- Sidr & Stone's oil is unfiltered extra virgin and may show natural sediment.
- Sidr & Stone's oil is 100% natural: one ingredient, no additives.
- Sidr & Stone uses matte black glass that blocks out light, with the ingredients and nutrition printed directly on the bottle in gold.
- Sidr & Stone has pledged 10% of its profits to charity.
- Sidr & Stone ships globally.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Frankies 457 Spuntino olive oil?
It is the olive oil line of Frankies 457, the specialty foods brand of the chefs behind Frankies 457 Spuntino in Brooklyn. The range has two extra virgins, Organic EVOO and Everyday Oil, plus a Calabrian chilli oil. The olives are described as grown and harvested in Selinunte, Sicily.
What does the 457 in Frankies 457 mean?
It is the street number of the original restaurant, Frankies 457 Spuntino, at 457 Court Street in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn. The food brand took its name from the restaurant, and the packaged-goods business trades separately as Frankies Specialty Foods LLC.
Who makes Frankies olive oil?
Frankies 457 is the brand owner, founded by chefs Frank Falcinelli and Frank Castronovo. Its about page has described the oil as made in partnership with the Asaro family in Sicily, and harvested, cold-pressed and packaged there. The partner's own specifications are not reproduced on the Frankies site.
What olives are in Frankies olive oil?
The Organic EVOO is made from Nocellara del Belice, a single variety better known as the Castelvetrano table olive. The Everyday Oil blends Nocellara del Belice with Biancolilla and Cerasuola. Expect a rounded, green style with moderate bitterness rather than a sharply peppery oil.
How high are Frankies 457 olive oil polyphenols?
Frankies does not publish a polyphenol figure for either extra virgin on its shop pages, checked 20 October 2026, so there is no number to quote. Nocellara del Belice oils are usually described as moderate rather than intense in bitterness, but only a lot-matched laboratory result would tell you the polyphenol content of a given bottle.
Is Frankies olive oil organic?
The brand describes its Organic EVOO as "a fully organic olive oil". The product description does not name a certifying body, so check the physical bottle for the organic seal and certifier code. The Everyday Oil is not described as organic, so treat the two oils differently if certification matters to you.
Where can you buy Frankies 457 olive oil?
From the brand's own online shop, where both extra virgins were listed at $36.99 per litre on 20 October 2026, and from US grocers including Whole Foods Market. Prefer a retailer with quick turnover and buy a size you will finish within a few months of opening.
How does Frankies compare with Sidr & Stone?
Frankies offers named Sicilian varieties and an oil it describes as fully organic. Sidr & Stone offers one single-estate Moroccan extra virgin from a farm we work ourselves: grown naturally, unfiltered, cold-pressed and with every batch independently tested.
Final Thoughts
Frankies 457 has a good story and tells it plainly: two chefs, a Court Street restaurant of nearly twenty years, and Sicilian oils with the locality and cultivars named. On what a label can verify, it is more forthcoming than much of the shelf; like most of the shelf, it does not publish dates or chemistry, so read the bottle in hand.
If you would rather trace your oil to a single estate, our Cold-Pressed Single-Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil - Marrakech (500ml) is available to order directly from us.
Our extra virgin olive oil comes from our own single-estate farm on the plains outside Marrakech, where we control every step from tree to bottle. The olives are grown naturally, with no pesticides, herbicides or chemical fertilisers.
Order Now: Sidr & Stone Cold-Pressed Single-Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil — Marrakech (500ml) →
Disclaimer: This article describes Frankies 457 and Frankies Specialty Foods LLC as they published themselves on frankies457.com and frankiesspuntino.com (shop listings rechecked on 20 October 2026); ranges, prices, certifications, label wording and site content may change, and readers should check current sources. We don't make medical claims about our oil. For any health concern, consult a qualified medical professional. Comparisons are made in good faith and in fair terms. Sidr & Stone is not affiliated with or endorsed by Frankies 457, the Asaro family or the retailers mentioned.

