Bowl of thick homemade olive oil mayonnaise with a whisk, brown eggs, halved lemons and golden-green olive oil

Olive Oil Mayo: How to Make It, and What's in the Shop Jars

Olive oil mayo takes about ten minutes to make at home, and the result is nothing like the jar that sits in most fridges. It needs one egg yolk, a little mustard and lemon, a pinch of salt and about 180 ml of olive oil. The catch is the oil itself: whisked hard, a strong extra virgin olive oil can turn a mayonnaise bitter and loose. The fix is to build the sauce on a mild olive oil and whisk the extra virgin in by hand at the end. This guide gives our recipe in metric and US cups, explains why the bitterness happens, sets out what the NHS and the US Food and Drug Administration say about raw eggs, and reads the ingredient lists on three olive oil mayonnaises sold today.

For the extra virgin part of the recipe, this is our own oil: Cold-Pressed Single-Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil - Marrakech (500ml).


The Short Answer

  • Olive oil mayo is an emulsion of oil, egg yolk and an acid such as lemon juice or vinegar. Our recipe makes about 210 g (roughly 1 cup) from one yolk and 180 ml (3/4 cup) of olive oil, and it is about four-fifths oil by weight.
  • Use a mild "light" olive oil for the base and whisk in extra virgin olive oil by hand at the end. Cooks widely report that strong extra virgin oil turns bitter in a blender, and a 2016 study in Food Chemistry found that olive phenolics make mayonnaise-like emulsions thinner and easier to break.
  • In the UK, the NHS says mayonnaise made with raw British Lion eggs, or hen eggs produced under the Laid in Britain scheme, is fine even in pregnancy. In the US, the FDA advises pasteurised eggs for any dish served with raw egg.
  • Many shop jars sold "with olive oil" are mostly something else. On 13 October 2026, the US Hellmann's and Duke's olive oil mayonnaises both listed water first, with canola and soybean oil after the olive oil.
  • A jar whose only oil is olive oil does exist: Hunter & Gather's UK Olive Oil Mayonnaise lists olive oil (80%) first and says it is made with light olive oil.
  • Sidr & Stone sells a single-estate extra virgin olive oil from Marrakech; in mayonnaise, it belongs in the hand-whisked finishing pour, not the whole batch.

Olive Oil Mayo: What You Need

This recipe makes about 210 g, or roughly 1 cup — enough for a week of sandwiches or one generous bowl of potato salad. It is deliberately small, because homemade mayonnaise has no preservatives and should be eaten fresh.

  • 1 large egg yolk (about 18 g) — see the food-safety section below for which eggs to use where you live
  • 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard (5 g)
  • 2 teaspoons lemon juice (10 ml), plus a little more to taste
  • 1 teaspoon white wine vinegar (5 ml)
  • 1/4 teaspoon fine salt (about 1.5 g)
  • 1 teaspoon cold water (5 ml)
  • 120 ml (1/2 cup) light-tasting olive oil — the refined "light" olive oil sold in most supermarkets
  • 60 ml (1/4 cup) extra virgin olive oil — the one you would happily eat on bread

Equipment: a medium bowl, a balloon whisk and a damp tea towel to stop the bowl spinning — or a stick blender and a tall jar only slightly wider than its head. US cup and spoon measures here are rounded to the nearest practical kitchen measure; the metric amounts are the ones we worked from.

Why two oils? Light olive oil is refined, so it has little flavour of its own and emulsifies easily; our guide to what "light" olive oil actually means explains how it is made. Using it for two-thirds of the oil gives a reliable, pale base. The final third, in extra virgin, is where the flavour comes from — and because it goes in by hand, it does not turn harsh.


How to Make Olive Oil Mayo, Step by Step

  1. Start the base. Set the bowl on the damp towel. Add the egg yolk, mustard, half the lemon juice, the salt and the water, and whisk for about 30 seconds until slightly paler.
  2. Add the light olive oil drop by drop. Whisking constantly, add the light olive oil a few drops at a time. After about 2 tablespoons the mixture will thicken and turn glossy — that is the emulsion forming.
  3. Speed up to a thin stream. Once it holds, pour the rest of the light olive oil in a thin, steady stream, still whisking. Pause the pouring, not the whisk, if oil starts to pool on the surface.
  4. Finish with extra virgin, by hand. Whisk in the extra virgin olive oil in a thin stream. Go gently: this is the step where heavy beating can bring out bitterness.
  5. Season and adjust. Taste, then add the rest of the lemon juice and the vinegar, and more salt if needed. If it is stiffer than you like, loosen it with a few drops of cold water.
  6. Chill straight away. Spoon it into a clean jar, cover it and refrigerate.

Stick-blender version. Put the yolk, mustard, half the lemon juice, salt and water in the tall jar and pour the light olive oil on top. Let it settle for a few seconds, press the blender head flat against the bottom, switch on and hold it there for 15–20 seconds until the mixture turns thick and pale, then lift it slowly to pull in the remaining oil. Tip the mayonnaise into a bowl and whisk in the extra virgin oil by hand, as in step 4 — not with the blender.

Total time is about ten minutes by whisk, three by blender. The finished sauce is a little looser and more golden than a shop jar, with a green, peppery edge from the extra virgin oil.

Stick blender standing in a tall glass jar of freshly made pale olive oil mayonnaise beside lemons and mustard


Why Extra Virgin Olive Oil Can Make Mayo Bitter

Ask anyone who has made mayonnaise with nothing but a robust extra virgin olive oil in a food processor, and many will describe the same thing: a sauce that tastes harsh, sometimes almost soapy-bitter, and that may refuse to thicken. Our own articles on olive oil substitutes make the same point — mayonnaise is one of the few jobs where a neutral oil is often the better choice.

The usual explanation is that extra virgin olive oil carries bitter phenolic compounds, and that very fast blending breaks the oil into tiny droplets and exposes more of them. We could not find a published sensory study that tests that bitterness directly, so treat it as well-founded kitchen experience rather than proven chemistry. What has been measured is the effect on texture. Giacintucci and colleagues (Food Chemistry, 2016; doi:10.1016/j.foodchem.2016.06.095) made mayonnaise-like emulsions with phenolic-rich extra virgin oils and with purified olive oil spiked with olive extract or oleuropein; the emulsions richer in phenolics had lower viscosity and yield stress and were easier to deform and break.

That is why the recipe above splits the job. A refined olive oil gives a stable emulsion; a modest share of extra virgin, whisked in by hand, adds flavour without being pounded. If you want an all-extra-virgin mayonnaise, it can be done: choose a mild, buttery extra virgin rather than a very peppery one, make it by hand, add the oil slowly and expect a looser, greener sauce. The compounds behind the bitterness are the same polyphenols that make good extra virgin worth eating, so this is a matter of technique, not a fault in the oil.


If Your Olive Oil Mayo Splits: How to Rescue It

A split mayonnaise looks thin, greasy and curdled, with oil sliding off the surface. It usually means the oil went in too quickly at the start, before the emulsion had formed. It is not wasted.

  1. Put a fresh egg yolk — or, if you would rather not use another egg, 1 teaspoon of Dijon mustard with 1 teaspoon of water — into a clean bowl.
  2. Whisk the split mixture into it a few drops at a time, exactly as you added the oil the first time.
  3. Once it thickens again, add the rest of the split mixture in a thin stream, then any oil you had not yet used.

If you are rescuing a batch, the same food-safety rules apply to the second yolk as to the first. The sauce made with the mustard-and-water rescue will be a little sharper; balance it with an extra squeeze of lemon and a pinch of salt.

Bowl of thin split oily mayonnaise beside a bowl of smooth thick rescued olive oil mayo and a whisk


Raw Eggs and Olive Oil Mayo: What the NHS and FDA Say

Homemade mayonnaise is a raw-egg sauce, and the advice on raw eggs differs by country. These are the official positions as we read them on 13 October 2026.

United Kingdom. The NHS page on foods to avoid in pregnancy says mayonnaise and mousse made with raw eggs are fine to eat if they are made with British Lion eggs or hen eggs produced under the Laid in Britain scheme, because these are less likely to contain salmonella. Hen eggs without the British Lion stamp, or not produced under Laid in Britain, should only be eaten well cooked — and duck, goose and quail eggs should always be well cooked.

United States. The FDA's egg safety guidance advises that recipes calling for eggs that are raw or undercooked when the dish is served — it names Caesar dressing and homemade ice cream — should use shell eggs treated to destroy salmonella, by pasteurisation or another approved method, or pasteurised egg products. The FDA lists children, older adults, pregnant women and people with weakened immune systems as being at greater risk of severe illness.

Everywhere else. If you live outside the UK and US, follow your own national food-safety authority. Where the advice is unclear, pasteurised eggs are the safest choice.

Storing it. The FDA says to keep egg dishes in the fridge at 40°F (about 4°C) or below and not to leave them out for more than 2 hours, or more than 1 hour above 90°F (about 32°C). None of the official pages we checked gives a shelf life for homemade mayonnaise, which is one reason this recipe is small: treat it as a fresh sauce, keep it covered and cold, and use it within a few days rather than the weeks a commercial jar lasts.

Covered glass jar of homemade mayonnaise beside a bowl of brown eggs on a clean, cool fridge shelf


What's in the Shop Jars: Reading an Olive Oil Mayo Label

"With olive oil" on a jar tells you olive oil is in it, not how much. The ingredient list does more work. In the UK and EU, ingredients must be listed "in descending order of weight", as recorded at the time of their use in manufacture (Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, Article 18, also in force in the UK as assimilated law). In the US, the rule is "descending order of predominance by weight" (21 CFR 101.4). So the first oil named is the main oil, and an ingredient listed before the oils outweighs every one of them.

We read three olive oil mayonnaises' published ingredient lists on 13 October 2026:

Jar (market) First ingredient Oils, in label order Egg
Hellmann's Mayonnaise Dressing with Olive Oil (US) Water Olive oil, canola oil, soybean oil Whole eggs, egg yolks
Duke's Light Mayonnaise with Olive Oil (US) Water Olive oil, canola oil, soybean oil Egg yolks
Hunter & Gather Olive Oil Mayonnaise (UK) Olive oil (80%) Olive oil only — "made with 100% light olive oil" Pasteurised British free-range egg yolk (9%)
Our homemade recipe Olive oil (about 79% of the weight) Light olive oil, then extra virgin olive oil One egg yolk

Hellmann's US jar also lists modified corn starch, sugar, distilled vinegar, salt, lemon juice concentrate, sorbic acid and calcium disodium EDTA, vitamin E, natural flavour and paprika extract. Duke's light version lists modified food starch, distilled and cider vinegar, sugar, salt, lemon juice, spice, xanthan gum, potassium sorbate, vitamin E, beta carotene, natural flavours and calcium disodium EDTA. Hunter & Gather's list is olive oil, egg yolk, apple cider vinegar and salt.

Two details are worth knowing. First, under the US standard of identity, a product sold as "mayonnaise" must contain not less than 65% vegetable oil by weight (21 CFR 169.140). The Hellmann's jar is named "Mayonnaise Dressing with Olive Oil" and the Duke's jar "Light Mayonnaise with Olive Oil", and both list water first. Second, if you are looking for a mayonnaise without seed oils, canola and soybean oil are both on the usual seed-oil lists — our seed oils list sets out which oils count and what the evidence actually says.

Light olive oil, used by Hunter & Gather and in the base of our recipe, is a refined olive oil product rather than extra virgin. That is a sensible choice for a mild, stable mayonnaise; it simply is not the same as extra virgin olive oil, and the label tells you so.

Two more jars show the range. Fratelli Carli, the Italian olive oil company, sells a Maionese all'Olio di Oliva in 160 g jars; on 20 October 2026 its Italian product page said it is made only with olive oil, plus eggs, vinegar and lemon, without additives or preservatives. In the US, Graza's "Original" Olive Oil Mayo (17 oz) is described on its product page as made with a mix of olive pomace oil and extra virgin olive oil, plus cage-free eggs. Olive pomace oil is a separate, refined grade made from the olive paste left after pressing, so, like light olive oil, it is not extra virgin.

Three unbranded mayonnaise jars with blank labels in different shades beside a brass magnifying glass and lemon


Is Olive Oil Mayo Better for You?

Swapping the oil changes the type of fat, not the amount. A mayonnaise made mostly of oil is a calorie-dense food whichever oil you choose. Hunter & Gather's olive oil mayonnaise lists 743 kcal and 83 g of fat per 100 g, of which 60.7 g is monounsaturated. Hellmann's US olive oil jar lists 60 kcal and 7 g of fat per 15 g tablespoon — and water, not oil, is its first ingredient.

What olive oil brings is a fat profile dominated by monounsaturated oleic acid and, in the extra virgin portion, its natural polyphenols. That is a reasonable reason to prefer an olive oil mayonnaise; it is not a reason to eat more of it. Use it as you would any mayonnaise — a spoonful, not a scoop.


Variations: Garlic, Lemon-Herb and Whole-Egg Mayo

  • Garlic mayonnaise. Crush 1 small garlic clove to a paste with the salt and whisk it into the base in step 1. Shop jars often call this aioli; the traditional Catalan allioli is simply garlic and olive oil pounded together, with no egg.
  • Lemon and herb. Stir in 1 teaspoon of finely grated lemon zest and 1 tablespoon (about 4 g) of chopped parsley, chives or tarragon once the mayonnaise is made.
  • Whole-egg mayonnaise. In the stick-blender version, you can use one whole egg (about 50 g) instead of the yolk and increase the light olive oil to 150 ml (about 2/3 cup). It comes out paler and slightly lighter in texture.
  • Mustard-forward. Double the Dijon for a sharper sauce to go with roast potatoes or a grain salad.

For other ways to put good olive oil to work raw, see our olive oil hummus recipe.


Why Sidr & Stone

We will be straight with you: you do not need a single-estate extra virgin olive oil for the base of a mayonnaise, and we would not use one there. Where it earns its place is the finishing pour — the 60 ml whisked in by hand, which is what you actually taste. Sidr & Stone's olive oil comes from our own single-estate farm on the plains outside Marrakech, Morocco, and we control every step from tree to bottle.

  • Single-estate: Sidr & Stone's olive oil comes from our own family-owned farm near Marrakech, with no blending across origins.
  • Grown naturally: no pesticides, herbicides or chemical fertilisers.
  • Picked when the fruit is ready — the product page has this harvest's details.
  • Cold-pressed.
  • Unfiltered extra virgin: minimally processed, so natural sediment may settle in the bottle.
  • 100% natural: a single ingredient, with nothing added.
  • Matte black glass that blocks out light: 500ml.
  • We have pledged 10% of our profits to charity.
  • We ship globally.

The honest answer to which olive oil is best for mayonnaise is that the best mayonnaise uses two oils. Ours is single-estate Moroccan, grown naturally and cold-pressed, and it belongs in the last spoonfuls of oil, the part you taste. For what to look for in any bottle, see our guide to choosing a quality olive oil.

Sidr & Stone extra virgin olive oil bottle beside a bowl of homemade mayonnaise, lemons and brown eggs


Frequently Asked Questions

Can you make mayo with olive oil?

Yes. Olive oil mayo is made exactly like ordinary mayonnaise: whisk one egg yolk with mustard, lemon juice and salt, then add the oil drop by drop until it thickens. For the most reliable result, use a mild light olive oil for most of the oil and whisk a smaller share of extra virgin olive oil in by hand at the end.

Why does my olive oil mayo taste bitter?

Usually because a strong extra virgin olive oil was beaten hard in a blender or food processor. Use a milder oil for the base, add the extra virgin by hand, and choose a buttery rather than very peppery extra virgin.

Is it safe to eat homemade mayo made with raw eggs?

In the UK, the NHS says mayonnaise made with raw British Lion or Laid in Britain hen eggs is fine, even in pregnancy. In the US, the FDA advises pasteurised eggs for any dish served with raw egg. Elsewhere, follow your national food-safety authority, and keep the mayonnaise chilled.

Is there a 100% olive oil mayo?

Yes. Hunter & Gather's UK Olive Oil Mayonnaise lists olive oil as its only oil and says it uses light olive oil. Fratelli Carli's Italian Maionese all'Olio di Oliva is another: its product page says it is made only with olive oil. Many jars sold "with olive oil" also contain canola or soybean oil, so read the ingredient list.

Does olive oil mayo have eggs?

Usually, yes. Mayonnaise is an emulsion held together by egg yolk, and all three shop jars in the table above list egg. For an egg-free sauce, the traditional Catalan allioli is simply garlic and olive oil pounded together, with no egg; check the label on any jar sold as egg-free to see what replaces the yolk.

Is it better to buy olive oil mayo or make it?

Making it takes about ten minutes, lets you choose the oil, and needs no preservatives, but it keeps only a few days and raises the raw-egg question. Buying is easier and keeps for weeks; the catch is that many jars sold "with olive oil" list water first and add canola or soybean oil, so read the ingredient list.

Is olive oil mayo the same as Sidr & Stone's olive oil?

No. Sidr & Stone sells a single-ingredient extra virgin olive oil, not a mayonnaise. In the recipe above, it is the extra virgin oil you whisk in at the end for flavour.

How long does homemade olive oil mayo keep?

No official source we checked gives a shelf life for homemade mayonnaise. Treat it as a fresh sauce: keep it covered in the fridge at 4°C (40°F) or below, never leave it out for more than 2 hours, and use it within a few days.

Where can I buy Sidr & Stone olive oil?

Directly from our website. Our single-estate Marrakech extra virgin olive oil is available to order directly from us.

Do you make medical claims about your oil?

No. We don't make medical claims about our oil. If you take medication, especially blood thinners such as warfarin, or are pregnant or breastfeeding, speak to your doctor first.


Final Thoughts

Olive oil mayo is one of the simplest things you can make in a kitchen, and one of the most satisfying. The two things that trip people up are the oil and the egg. The oil problem is solved by splitting the job — a mild olive oil for the body of the sauce, a good extra virgin whisked in at the end for flavour. The egg question is answered by your national food-safety authority: British Lion or Laid in Britain eggs in the UK, pasteurised eggs in the US.

If you would rather buy a jar, read the ingredient list before the front label. The first ingredient and the order of the oils tell you far more than the words "with olive oil".

Our Cold-Pressed Single-Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil - Marrakech (500ml) is single-estate — the oil for the finishing pour. It is available to order directly from us.

Sidr & Stone olive oil bottle with gold pourer beside a herby potato salad and a dish of mayonnaise

Our extra virgin olive oil comes from our own single-estate farm on the plains outside Marrakech, where we control every step from tree to bottle. The olives are grown naturally, with no pesticides, herbicides or chemical fertilisers.

Order Now: Sidr & Stone Cold-Pressed Single-Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil — Marrakech (500ml) →


Disclaimer: This article describes official food-safety advice, labelling rules, a published study and manufacturers' published ingredient lists as they stood at the time of writing (13 October 2026); advice, recipes and formulations may change, and readers should check current sources. References to other brands describe their own published ingredient lists in good faith and are not affiliated with or endorsed by those brands. Homemade mayonnaise contains raw egg; follow your national food-safety authority's advice on eggs, especially if you are pregnant, cooking for young children or older adults, or have a weakened immune system. We don't make medical claims about our oil. For any health concern, consult a qualified medical professional.

Back to blog