Stop & Shop Olive Oil: What the Own-Brand Range Declares
By Yusuf Elsayed, Founder of Sidr & Stone · Last updated 20 November 2026Share
If you have searched for Stop & Shop olive oil, you are probably standing in front of the cooking-oil shelf, or filling an online basket, and wondering which of the store's own bottles to take. The Stop & Shop own-brand range is wider than it first looks: three grades in up to five sizes, plus an organic extra virgin under the Nature's Promise label. When we read Stop & Shop's own product listings on 8 October 2026, each one declared its ingredients, its intended use and its countries of origin. This guide sets out what those declarations say, what they mean in plain English, and which bottle suits which job. It also covers the branded oils on the same shelf and the questions no supermarket listing can answer.
The Short Answer
- On 8 October 2026, Stop & Shop's "Our Brand Olive Oil" listing showed 13 own-brand bottles: Stop & Shop Extra Virgin (8.5, 16.9, 25.3, 50.7 and 101 oz), Classic (16.9, 25.3, 50.7 and 101 oz), Extra Light Tasting (16.9, 25.3 and 50.7 oz) and Nature's Promise Organic Extra Virgin (16.9 oz).
- Stop & Shop Extra Virgin Olive Oil lists one ingredient, extra virgin olive oil, and is described as "First cold extracted" and "For dressing & marinating".
- Stop & Shop Classic and Extra Light Tasting both list "Refined Olive Oil, Virgin Olive Oil". They are blends for cooking, not extra virgin oils, and all three grades declare the same 120 calories per tablespoon.
- The Stop & Shop own-brand oils are imported from Spain but may contain oil from several countries; the 16.9 oz extra virgin listing names Argentina, Greece, Italy, Morocco, Portugal, Spain, Tunisia and Turkey.
- Nature's Promise Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil is the range's certified option: its listing says "USDA organic" and "Certified organic by SC CAAE ES-ECO-001-AN".
- No own-brand listing we read gave a harvest date, an acidity figure or a polyphenol figure. That is normal for supermarket oil, so the label on the bottle in your hand is the best information you will get.
What Stop & Shop's Own-Brand Olive Oil Range Includes
Stop & Shop sells its everyday own label under the Stop & Shop name and its organic line under Nature's Promise. We built the table below from stopandshop.com on 8 October 2026, with one New York store (ZIP 10541) selected. Ranges vary by store, so treat it as a guide to what exists rather than a stock check.
| Own-brand product | Sizes listed | Ingredients declared | Use stated on the listing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stop & Shop Extra Virgin Olive Oil | 8.5, 16.9, 25.3, 50.7, 101 oz | Extra virgin olive oil | "For dressing & marinating" |
| Stop & Shop Classic Olive Oil | 16.9, 25.3, 50.7, 101 oz | Refined olive oil, virgin olive oil | "For sauteing & grilling" |
| Stop & Shop Extra Light Tasting Olive Oil | 16.9, 25.3, 50.7 oz | Refined olive oil, virgin olive oil | "For frying & baking" |
| Nature's Promise Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil | 16.9 fl oz (500ml) | Organic extra virgin olive oil | "For dressing & marinating" |
A wider search for olive oil on the same site also returned a Stop & Shop Olive Oil Non-Stick Cooking Spray (5 oz), which is for greasing pans rather than dressing food. The manufacturer named on the Stop & Shop-label listings is Foodhold USA LLC; on the Nature's Promise listing it is Ahold USA, Inc. of Landover, Maryland. The Giant chains' own-label listings follow a very similar pattern, which our guide to Giant olive oil covers from Giant's own websites.

Extra Virgin, Classic or Extra Light: Read the Ingredient Line
The fastest way to tell Stop & Shop's three grades apart is to skip the front label and read the ingredients. Stop & Shop Extra Virgin lists a single ingredient: extra virgin olive oil. Classic and Extra Light Tasting each list two, "Refined Olive Oil, Virgin Olive Oil". That word "refined" is the one that matters.
Refined olive oil has been processed to remove flavour, colour and defects, so on its own it tastes of very little. Packers blend it with virgin oil to give back some olive character. The USDA's grade standards have a name for exactly that mix: "U.S. Olive Oil", defined as "a blend of refined olive oil and virgin olive oils". It is a legitimate grade with its own uses. It is not extra virgin, and "Classic" and "Extra Light Tasting" are product names rather than grades. Our explainers on classic olive oil and light olive oil go further.
One point surprises many shoppers. Stop & Shop's listings give 120 calories per tablespoon for the Extra Virgin, the Classic and the Extra Light Tasting alike. "Extra light" describes a milder taste and paler colour, not fewer calories — the same is true of national brands, as our look at Bertolli Extra Light olive oil shows.

Where Stop & Shop Own-Brand Olive Oil Comes From
The 16.9 oz Extra Virgin, 25.3 oz Classic and 25.3 oz Extra Light Tasting listings carry the same country-of-origin statement: "Argentina, Imported From Spain. Contains Oil From One Or More Of These Countries: Greece, Italy, Morocco, Portugal, Spain, Tunisia, Turkey". In plain terms, the oil is packed and shipped from Spain, but the olives behind any given bottle may have been grown in one or several of those countries.
The 101 oz Extra Virgin listing is more specific about where to look. It says the "Best by, Lot no. and country of origin" information is printed on the bottle, and its code list adds Chile, the United States and Uruguay. So for the biggest jug, the bottle itself tells you which countries went into that particular lot.
Multi-country blending is standard practice for supermarket own labels, and it is not a fault. It lets a packer keep the taste and the price steady from year to year. The trade-off is that you are buying a style, not a place. Interestingly, Morocco is on the list; our guide to Moroccan olive oil covers Moroccan oil as a single origin in its own right.

Nature's Promise Organic: The Certified Bottle in the Range
Nature's Promise Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil is the own-brand bottle with a formal certification. Its listing reads "USDA organic", "First cold pressed" and "Non GMO project. Verified.", and it names its certifier: "Certified organic by SC CAAE ES-ECO-001-AN". The code ES-ECO-001-AN belongs to Servicio de Certificación CAAE, an organic control body based in Seville and listed in the Andalusian government's directory of organic certifiers. The listing gives the countries of origin as Argentina, Italy, Spain and Tunisia, and the size as 16.9 fl oz (500ml).
That is a genuine strength, and we credit it plainly. A named certifier and a USDA organic seal are formal checks on how the olives were grown, which is more than most supermarket oils offer. For more on what organic certification does and does not tell you, see our guide to organic olive oil.
Two phrases are worth decoding. "First cold extracted" (on the Stop & Shop Extra Virgin) and "First cold pressed" (on Nature's Promise) both describe extraction temperature. In the European marketing rules that Spanish packers work under, published on legislation.gov.uk as Regulation 29/2012, Article 5, "cold extraction" and "first cold pressing" may appear only on virgin or extra virgin oils obtained below 27°C. They tell you how the oil was made, not how fresh it is. Our explainer on cold-extracted olive oil covers the detail.
The Branded Olive Oils on Stop & Shop's Shelf
The same 8 October search returned 153 results for "olive oil", and the national brands sat alongside the own label. The table lists the olive oils that appeared on the first page, by the names on the listings.
| Brand | Olive oils listed | Our brand guide |
|---|---|---|
| Colavita | First Cold Pressed Extra Virgin; Premium First Cold Pressed Extra Virgin | Colavita olive oil |
| Filippo Berio | Extra Virgin; Olive Oil for Sauteing & Grilling; Extra Light Tasting | Filippo Berio olive oil |
| Bertolli | Rich Taste Extra Virgin; Extra Light Taste | Bertolli olive oil |
| Pompeian | Smooth Extra Virgin; Robust Extra Virgin | Pompeian olive oil |
| Terra Delyssa | Extra Virgin; Organic Extra Virgin | Terra Delyssa olive oil |
| Graza | Sizzle Extra Virgin; Drizzle Extra Virgin | Graza olive oil |
| Goya | First Cold Press Extra Virgin | Goya olive oil |
The pattern matches the own label. Most brands sell an extra virgin oil alongside a blend sold as "light", "extra light" or for sautéing, and the blend names are not quality grades. Turn any bottle round and read the ingredient line and the origin statement before you choose.
How to Choose an Olive Oil at Stop & Shop
Six checks will sort almost any bottle on the shelf, own label or branded:
- Read the ingredient line first. "Extra virgin olive oil" alone means an unrefined oil; "refined olive oil" means a blend.
- Treat "Classic", "Extra Light" and plain "Olive Oil" as blend names. None is a grade, and none means fewer calories.
- Match the bottle to the job. Stop & Shop's own listings point the way: extra virgin for dressing, Classic for sautéing, Extra Light for frying and baking.
- Look for a harvest date. A best-before date tells you the shelf policy; a harvest date tells you the oil's real age.
- Check the origin on the bottle. On the large jugs, the lot's country codes are printed on the container.
- Buy a size you will finish. The 101 oz jug is good value only if you use it before it goes stale, and storing it away from light and heat, as the listings advise, helps.
For the fuller checklist, see our guide to choosing a quality olive oil, and for the supermarket decision in general, our guide to the best grocery store olive oil.

Three Fair Objections
"Cheap own-label extra virgin can't really be extra virgin." We cannot tell you either way, and neither can a listing. Stop & Shop's bottle is labelled extra virgin and described as first cold extracted, which is consistent with the grade. What it does not publish is a laboratory result, which is true of almost every supermarket oil. A fresh extra virgin oil should smell and taste of olives, often with some bitterness or a peppery catch.
"An online listing isn't my store." True. The listings we used are a snapshot of one store on one day. Use them to know what to look for, then read the label on the shelf.
"You sell olive oil, so you're not neutral." Also true, and you should read the next section with that in mind. We have kept to what Stop & Shop's listings say.
How Stop & Shop's Olive Oils Compare with a Single-Estate Oil
Stop & Shop genuinely leads on convenience and choice: several grades and sizes on a shelf near you, and in Nature's Promise a USDA-organic bottle certified by CAAE, a certificate we do not hold. Where a single-estate oil differs is in telling you exactly where it comes from — one grove rather than a blend of countries.
| What a buyer might want to see | Stop & Shop Extra Virgin | Nature's Promise Organic Extra Virgin | Sidr & Stone |
|---|---|---|---|
| Origin | Imported from Spain; oil from one or more of several countries | Argentina, Italy, Spain, Tunisia | One estate on the plains outside Marrakech, Morocco |
| Extraction | "First cold extracted" | "First cold pressed" | Cold-pressed |
| Organic status | Not stated | USDA organic, certified by CAAE | Grown naturally; not certified organic |
| Harvest details | Not on the listing | Not on the listing | On the product page; every bottle traceable |
| Testing | No figures on the listing | No figures on the listing | Every batch independently tested |
If a convenient, certified-organic everyday bottle is what you need, Nature's Promise covers it. If you would rather trace your oil to one farm and one batch, our Cold-Pressed Single-Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil - Marrakech (500ml) is made for that.
Why Sidr & Stone
Sidr & Stone makes one olive oil, from one farm we work ourselves, and every bottle can be traced.
- Sidr & Stone's olive oil is single-estate: it comes from our own family-owned farm near Marrakech, Morocco, with every step controlled from tree to bottle and no blending across origins.
- Sidr & Stone's olives are grown without pesticides, herbicides or chemical fertilisers.
- Every batch of Sidr & Stone's oil is independently tested.
- Our olives are picked when the fruit is ready; the product page has this harvest's details.
- Sidr & Stone's oil is cold-pressed, with no refining.
- Sidr & Stone's oil is unfiltered extra virgin and may show natural sediment, which is normal.
- Sidr & Stone's oil is 100% natural: one ingredient, with no additives.
- It is bottled in matte black glass that blocks out light.
- We have pledged 10% of our profits to charity.
- We ship globally.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Stop & Shop sell its own olive oil?
Yes. On 8 October 2026 its website listed Stop & Shop Extra Virgin, Classic and Extra Light Tasting olive oils in several sizes, a Nature's Promise Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil, and a Stop & Shop olive oil cooking spray.
Where does Stop & Shop extra virgin olive oil come from?
The listing says it is imported from Spain and may contain oil from Argentina, Greece, Italy, Morocco, Portugal, Spain, Tunisia or Turkey. On the 101 oz jug, the lot's country of origin is printed on the bottle.
What is the difference between Stop & Shop Classic and Extra Virgin olive oil?
The ingredients. Extra Virgin is a single unrefined oil. Classic lists refined olive oil and virgin olive oil, a milder blend that the listing suggests for sautéing and grilling.
Is Stop & Shop Extra Light Tasting olive oil lower in calories?
No. Its listing gives 120 calories per tablespoon, the same as the Extra Virgin and the Classic. "Extra light" refers to a milder taste and paler colour from the refined oil in the blend.
How does Sidr & Stone compare with Stop & Shop's olive oils?
Stop & Shop offers convenience, several grades and sizes, and a certified organic option in Nature's Promise. Ours is one extra virgin oil from one estate outside Marrakech, cold-pressed, unfiltered, and grown naturally.
Is Nature's Promise olive oil certified organic?
Yes. The Stop & Shop listing for Nature's Promise Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil says "USDA organic" and names its certifier as CAAE (code ES-ECO-001-AN). It is also labelled Non-GMO Project Verified.
Can I buy Stop & Shop olive oil online?
Yes. Stop & Shop's website offers delivery and pickup as well as in-store shopping, and its store pages say it operates more than 300 stores across New York, New England and New Jersey. Prices and stock vary by store.
Do you make medical claims about your oil?
No. We don't make medical claims about our oil. If you take medication, especially blood thinners such as warfarin, or are pregnant or breastfeeding, speak to your doctor first.
Final Thoughts
Stop & Shop's olive oil shelf is easy to read once you know what the labels declare. The Stop & Shop Extra Virgin is the own-brand bottle for flavour, a multi-country oil imported from Spain. Classic and Extra Light Tasting are refined blends for cooking. Nature's Promise Organic is the certified extra virgin, and it deserves the credit its USDA seal brings.
What no supermarket listing gives you is the grove, the harvest or the analysis. For everyday frying that matters little. When the oil itself is the point of the dish, it is worth asking who grew it and where it comes from. Stop & Shop's history goes back to a single Economy Grocery Store in Somerville, Massachusetts, in 1914; ours goes back to a single estate.
For readers who want to know the grove, our Cold-Pressed Single-Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil - Marrakech (500ml) — single-estate, cold-pressed and independently tested batch by batch — is available to order directly from us. For other names you may see on a Northeast shelf, our guides to ShopRite olive oil and the olive oil brands A–Z are good next stops.
Our extra virgin olive oil comes from our own single-estate farm on the plains outside Marrakech, where we control every step from tree to bottle. The olives are grown naturally, with no pesticides, herbicides or chemical fertilisers.
Order Now: Sidr & Stone Cold-Pressed Single-Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil — Marrakech (500ml) →
Disclaimer: This article describes Stop & Shop's website and product listings as they stood on 8 October 2026, along with the USDA grade standards and EU-derived labelling rules; ranges, label wording, sizes and certifications may change, and readers should check current labels and listings. References to Stop & Shop, Nature's Promise and the other brands named describe general retail observations and are not affiliated with or endorsed by Stop & Shop, its parent company or those brands. Comparisons are made in good faith and in fair terms. We don't make medical claims about our oil. For any health concern, consult a qualified medical professional.

