Lucero Olive Oil: An Honest Review of the California Producer
By Yusuf Elsayed, Founder of Sidr & Stone · Last updated 20 November 2026Share
Lucero olive oil is a Californian brand from Corning, now sold online by American Olive Farmer, the business of Liz Tagami and Donald Shaw. It no longer runs its own mill and works with growers and millers certified by the Olive Oil Commission of California. Its single-variety extra virgins are Arbequina, Ascolano and Taggiasca, mostly from Crane family orchards near Corning. Product pages give harvest years and lab figures, up to 751.5 mg/kg polyphenols for the Taggiasca. No organic claim is made. Checked 8 October 2026.
The Short Answer
- Lucero Olive Oil is a Californian extra virgin olive oil brand from Corning, now sold online through American Olive Farmer, which its About page describes as a small Northern California business run by Liz Tagami and her husband, Donald Shaw. The brand is still trading.
- American Olive Farmer's About page states that it no longer operates a company-owned olive mill; it partners with growers, millers and bottlers certified by the Olive Oil Commission of California.
- On 8 October 2026 the shop listed Lucero Arbequina (750ml), Ascolano (500ml), Taggiasca High-Polyphenol (250ml) and a Mission Olio Novello (500ml, single bottles sold out), plus co-milled lemon, co-milled Genovese basil and roasted garlic oils.
- Several product pages publish a harvest year and lab figures: the Taggiasca page states 751.5 mg/kg total biophenols by HPLC, measured by Modern Olives Laboratory.
- The fruit for most of the range comes from orchards developed by the Crane family near Corning; the Olio Novello was made from Mission olives grown in the Livermore Valley.
Who Makes Lucero Olive Oil Today?
Lucero began, by its own account, as a cottage business in Corning, Tehama County, and became a California LLC in January 2009. American Olive Farmer's orchards page ties that step to the development of the Hall Road orchard, which the Crane family converted from rice fields into olives around 2008 and 2009.
Liz Tagami is the person most closely associated with the brand now. The About page says she spent more than 25 years as a merchant and executive with national specialty retailers, began working with Lucero Olive Oil in 2008, became a co-owner in 2015 and, in 2022, relaunched Lucero with her husband Donald as part of American Olive Farmer, a direct-to-consumer business. The page also says she has served on sensory panels and international juries, and evaluates the oils each harvest.
American Olive Farmer sells more than Lucero. The same site offers fresh raw olives for home curing, olive trees, tasting supplies and Modenese balsamic vinegars for which it acts as négociant. For this review we look only at the Lucero oils.

Is the Lucero Mill in Corning Still Running?
Not as Lucero's own mill. American Olive Farmer's About page states plainly: "we no longer operate a company-owned olive mill". It says the business now partners exclusively with growers, millers and bottlers who are certified by the Olive Oil Commission of California, and stays involved through harvest and evaluation.
That explains the confusion online. Older coverage, including a local news feature on the Lucero Olive Oil Mill and Tasting Room in Corning, describes a working mill and a visitor tasting room. If you were planning a visit, the current contact details on the site are a Corning post office box, an email address and a phone number, and the oils ship by courier. The product pages still say each oil is "grown, milled, and bottled in California".
For buyers, this matters less than it sounds. Many respected producers use a partner mill; what counts is whether the bottle tells you which fruit, which harvest and what condition the oil was in when tested, and here Lucero is more forthcoming than most.

The Lucero Range, Checked 8 October 2026
These are the Lucero oils in American Olive Farmer's public product feed and on its product pages on the day we checked, with the harvest year, the polyphenol figure and the laboratory each page gives.
| Oil | Size | Harvest stated | Total polyphenols stated | Laboratory named |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lucero Arbequina Extra Virgin Olive Oil | 750ml (also a trio) | 2025 | 446.8, via HPLC (units not stated) | Not named |
| Lucero Ascolano Extra Virgin Olive Oil | 500ml | 2024 | 584 mg/kg | Not named |
| Lucero Taggiasca High-Polyphenol Extra Virgin Olive Oil | 250ml | 2024 | 751.5 mg/kg by HPLC | Modern Olives Laboratory |
| Lucero Mission Olio Novello | 500ml (final trio packs only) | 26 November 2025 | 359.4 mg/kg by HPLC | Modern Olives Laboratory |
| Lucero Co-Milled Lemon Olive Oil | 250ml (also a trio) | 2024; "enjoy by April 2027" | Not stated | Not applicable |
| Lucero Co-Milled Genovese Basil and Roasted Garlic oils | 250ml (also trios) | Not checked in detail | Not stated | Not applicable |
The Arbequina and Ascolano pages also say each oil is "verified extra virgin by the Olive Oil Commission of California (CDFA)". The commission's own FAQ describes mandatory grade standards, with sampling by California Department of Food and Agriculture officials and testing by accredited labs, for producers handling more than 5,000 gallons a year. Our guide to California olive oil brands explains how the state's schemes differ.

The Four Single-Variety Oils, Bottle by Bottle
Arbequina, 750ml
The everyday bottle. The page says it is grown and milled in California and blended lot by lot from parts of the orchard harvested a week or two apart, in what it calls "an earlier-harvest style", with green apple, herbs and a pungent finish of toasted almond. It comes in a tall antique-green glass bottle, and the page lists 2025 harvest, free fatty acidity of 0.17 and a suggestion to use it within four weeks of opening. Our piece on the Arbequina olive explains why the cultivar is usually milder than this.
Ascolano, 500ml
The distinctive one. The page describes a ripe-fruity oil with peach, tropical fruit and herbs, and tells a good local story: Ascolano was planted around Corning for table olives, proved too soft for cannery equipment, and turned out to make an unusually aromatic oil. The page quotes Paul Vossen, Specialty Crop Farm Advisor Emeritus at University of California ANR, calling it "a fantastic example of a ripe, fruity oil". The listed harvest is 2024.
Taggiasca High-Polyphenol, 250ml
The intense one. Taggiasca is known in Liguria for gentle oil; Lucero says its fruit comes from a small planting south of Corning, harvested earlier, and is distinctly bitter and peppery. This page carries the most detail: 751.5 mg/kg total biophenols, 116.3 mg/kg oleacein and 94.5 mg/kg oleocanthal, a Rancimat induction time of 43.7 hours, and the laboratory named. The listed harvest is 2024. Our guide to Taggiasca olives covers the cultivar in Italy.
Mission Olio Novello, 500ml
The seasonal one, and nearly gone. Mission is California's heritage olive; the page says Lucero offered it from 2008 to 2011, then returned to it for this 2025 novello, from Livermore Valley fruit harvested on 26 November 2025 and bottled unfiltered. On 8 October 2026 single bottles were sold out and the last trio packs were on offer.
The Published Lab Numbers, and How to Read Them
Lucero's pages use measurements that most supermarket labels never mention. Here is what each one tells you, in plain terms.
- Harvest date or year. The most useful single fact on any bottle. Olive oil is best young; a 2024 harvest bought in late 2026 is close to two years from the tree.
- Free fatty acidity (FFA). How much the oil's fats had broken down at testing, a sign of fruit condition and speed to the mill. The extra virgin limit is 0.8%; the Arbequina page lists 0.17 and the novello 0.09%.
- Total polyphenols (biophenols). The compounds behind bitterness, pungency and keeping quality. Higher means a more assertive oil, not a better one.
- DAGs and PPPs. Two freshness markers: DAGs tend to fall and PPPs tend to rise as oil ages or is exposed to heat, so they hint at how fresh the oil was when tested.
- Rancimat induction time. An accelerated oxidation test of how well the oil resists going stale. The novello page translates its 38.2 hours into roughly 38 months of shelf life.
- Named laboratory. The Taggiasca and novello pages name Modern Olives Laboratory, which makes those figures more traceable than an unnamed result.
Two cautions. Every figure is a snapshot from the day of testing, and polyphenols and freshness markers drift as the bottle sits. And not every figure arrives with units or a laboratory: the Arbequina's 446.8 has no units, and the lab is named on two of the four pages. Our guides to olive oil polyphenols and high phenolic olive oil explain what a fully traceable result looks like.

The Co-Milled and Flavoured Oils
Lucero's flavoured oils are worth separating from the extra virgin range. The shop lists a co-milled lemon oil, a co-milled Genovese basil oil and a roasted garlic oil; we read the lemon page in detail. It says fresh Lisbon and Meyer lemons are crushed and milled together with late-season California olives, extracted mechanically, with no added aromas, extracts or flavourings, and that the finished oil contains only two ingredients. That co-milling method is a traditional way to make a citrus oil, and different from oil simply infused with lemon flavouring. Its ingredients line reads "extra virgin olive oil and lemons", and the page gives a 2024 harvest with an "enjoy by" date of April 2027.
Because the lemons go into the mill with the olives, a co-milled oil is a flavoured olive oil, not a single-ingredient extra virgin. Our guide to lemon olive oil explains the difference between co-milled and infused.
Is Lucero Olive Oil Good? How to Choose a Bottle
On what its pages publish, Lucero is a carefully made Californian range with more open data than most brands: named cultivars, harvest years, freshness markers and, for two oils, a named laboratory. Whether it suits you depends on the bottle.
- Pick by flavour. Arbequina for everyday cooking and dressing, Ascolano for a ripe, fruity finishing oil, Taggiasca if you want bitterness and pepper.
- Check the harvest year against today's date. Two of the four single-variety oils were listed as 2024 harvest in October 2026; buy the freshest that suits you and use it promptly.
- Read the polyphenol figure as a flavour signal. 751.5 mg/kg means a bold, peppery oil; it is not a ranking of quality.
- Match the bottle size to your use. The pages advise using the oils within four to twelve weeks of opening; the 250ml Taggiasca suits occasional finishing use.
For the full checklist, our guide to choosing a quality olive oil covers grades, labels and tasting, and our piece on harvest dates and freshness explains why the pressing date matters more than a best-before date.
How Lucero Compares with a Single-Estate Oil
Lucero publishes harvest years, polyphenol figures, freshness markers and, for two oils, the laboratory's name, and it offers a choice of cultivars and bottle sizes — we publish none of that chemistry yet. For a US buyer, a Californian oil is also closer to home. A single-estate oil makes a different promise: one farm we work ourselves, picked when the fruit is ready, unfiltered, with every bottle traceable.
| Lucero (as stated, 8 October 2026) | Sidr & Stone Marrakech (500ml) | |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Northern California, mainly Crane family orchards near Corning | One family-owned farm outside Marrakech, Morocco |
| Milling | Certified partner millers; no company-owned mill | We control every step from tree to bottle |
| Range | Several single-variety oils plus co-milled oils | One unfiltered extra virgin olive oil |
| Published lab data | Harvest year, polyphenols and freshness markers | None published; every batch independently tested |
| Organic | Not claimed on the pages we read | Grown naturally, not certified organic |
If a published spec sheet or a choice of Californian cultivars matters most, Lucero is the better fit. If you want one oil from a single farm, our Cold-Pressed Single-Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil - Marrakech (500ml) is made for that. Our pieces on single-estate olive oil and Moroccan olive oil explain the approach and the origin.
Why Sidr & Stone
Sidr & Stone makes one olive oil, from one farm we work ourselves, and every bottle can be traced.
- Sidr & Stone's olive oil is single-estate: one family-owned farm on the plains outside Marrakech, Morocco, with no blending across origins.
- The grove is grown naturally, with no pesticides, herbicides or chemical fertilisers.
- Every batch is independently tested.
- The olives are cold-pressed.
- The oil is unfiltered extra virgin, minimally processed, and may show natural sediment.
- It is 100% natural: one ingredient, olive oil, nothing added.
- It is bottled in 500ml matte black glass that blocks out light, with the ingredients and nutrition printed directly on the bottle in gold.
- We have pledged 10% of our profits to charity.
- We ship globally.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Lucero olive oil still in business?
Yes. Lucero Olive Oil is sold online by American Olive Farmer, the direct-to-consumer business Liz Tagami relaunched it under in 2022. On 8 October 2026 the site listed Arbequina, Ascolano and Taggiasca extra virgin oils, a Mission olio novello in its final packs, and co-milled lemon, basil and roasted garlic oils.
Is the Lucero olive mill in Corning still open?
Not as Lucero's own mill. American Olive Farmer's About page says it no longer operates a company-owned olive mill and works with certified partner growers, millers and bottlers instead. The current contact address is a post office box in Corning, California, and the oils are shipped by courier rather than sold from a tasting room.
Where do Lucero's olives come from?
Mainly from two orchards near Corning developed by the Crane family, Hall Road and Williams 160, according to the brand's orchards page. The Hall Road orchard was converted from rice fields to olives around 2008 and 2009. The 2025 Mission olio novello was made from olives grown in the Livermore Valley.
Which Lucero olive oil has the most polyphenols?
The Taggiasca High-Polyphenol oil, at 751.5 mg/kg total biophenols by HPLC on the product page, from Modern Olives Laboratory. The Ascolano page lists 584 mg/kg. Higher figures mean a more bitter and peppery oil, not automatically a better one, and every figure is a snapshot from the day of testing.
Is Lucero olive oil certified extra virgin?
The Arbequina and Ascolano product pages say each oil is verified extra virgin by the Olive Oil Commission of California, the state body whose grade standards include mandatory sampling by state officials and testing by accredited labs for producers handling more than 5,000 gallons a year.
Who owns Lucero Olive Oil?
American Olive Farmer's About page names Liz Tagami, who began working with Lucero in 2008, became a co-owner in 2015 and relaunched the brand with her husband, Donald Shaw, in 2022. Lucero became a California LLC in January 2009, having started as a cottage business in Corning.
How does Sidr & Stone's olive oil compare with Lucero?
Lucero offers several Californian single-variety oils with published lab data from partner mills. Sidr & Stone sells one unfiltered extra virgin oil from a single farm we work outside Marrakech, grown naturally and every batch independently tested, though we do not publish lab figures.
Do you make medical claims about your oil?
No. We don't make medical claims about our oil. If you take medication, especially blood thinners such as warfarin, or are pregnant or breastfeeding, speak to your doctor first.
Final Thoughts
Lucero olive oil is a long-standing Californian name that has changed shape: no longer a mill with a tasting room, but a small online business working with certified partner growers and mills, and publishing more about its oils than most brands do. The Arbequina, Ascolano and Taggiasca are distinct, well-described oils, and the lab figures on their pages are a genuine strength. Watch the harvest year, choose by flavour, and finish the bottle while it is fresh.
If you would rather have an oil you can trace to one farm, our Cold-Pressed Single-Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil - Marrakech (500ml) is available to order directly from us. For other Californian producers, see our guide to California olive oil and our olive oil brands A–Z.
Our extra virgin olive oil comes from our own single-estate farm on the plains outside Marrakech, where we control every step from tree to bottle. The olives are grown naturally, with no pesticides, herbicides or chemical fertilisers.
Order Now: Sidr & Stone Cold-Pressed Single-Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil — Marrakech (500ml) →
Disclaimer: This article describes the Lucero olive oil products and published statements on americanolivefarmer.com, including its product pages, About and orchards pages and public product feed, as read on 8 October 2026; product ranges, harvests, specifications and availability may change, so check current sources. Olive Oil Commission of California details are from the commission's published FAQ. Comparisons are made in good faith and in fair terms. Sidr & Stone is not affiliated with or endorsed by Lucero Olive Oil or American Olive Farmer. We don't make medical claims about our oil. For any health concern, consult a qualified medical professional.

