Rows of gnarled old olive trees on golden Sicilian farmland at sunset with hazy hills and sea beyond

Rustico Olive Oil: An Honest Review and How It Compares

Rustico olive oil, in the sense most shoppers mean it, is Il Rustico di Casa Asaro: an unfiltered extra virgin olive oil from the Asaro family's olive farms in the Belice Valley of south-western Sicily, sold in the United States through H-E-B. The name causes some confusion, because at least two other oils on sale also carry the word "Rustico". This review sorts out which is which, then looks at what the Asaro brand, H-E-B and the competition record actually say about the bottle. We checked the brand's own website, H-E-B's listings and the New York International Olive Oil Competition's published results on 8 October 2026. It is a document-based review rather than a tasting, and it credits what is genuinely on the record while keeping clear what is not.

For our own oil, see our Cold-Pressed Single-Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil - Marrakech (500ml).


The Short Answer

  • "Rustico olive oil" in US search results almost always means Il Rustico di Casa Asaro®, a Sicilian brand the Asaro family created in partnership with the Texas grocer H-E-B, and which its website says is found exclusively at H-E-B.
  • The flagship is Rustico Extra Virgin Unfiltered in a 33.8 fl oz (1 L) bottle; the brand's site lists its ingredients as 100% extra virgin olive oil (unfiltered).
  • H-E-B describes the olives as grown on an estate in south-western Sicily, hand-picked and pressed within hours of harvest.
  • The producer behind it, Oleificio Asaro dal 1916, also makes Partanna and the Frankies 457 oils. At the 2026 NYIOOC, Il Rustico di Casa Asaro won a Silver Award and was listed as a blend.
  • There is a separate USDA certified organic Rustico (750 mL) and a set of flavoured oils, which the brand says it makes with partner producers.
  • Filippo Berio Rustico and Borrelli Rustico are different products from different companies.
  • Sidr & Stone sells one single-estate Moroccan extra virgin olive oil. It is grown naturally, and it has no published laboratory figure or awards.

Which Rustico Is This? Three Oils Share the Name

"Rustico" simply means "rustic" in Italian, so it turns up on more than one label. We checked each one at its own source on 8 October 2026, and three are worth telling apart:

Label Who is behind it What it is Where it is sold
Il Rustico di Casa Asaro The Asaro family (Oleificio Asaro dal 1916), Sicily; US company United Olive Oil Import Corp., New York Unfiltered extra virgin olive oil (1 L), a USDA organic version (750 mL) and flavoured oils H-E-B stores and heb.com, which the brand describes as exclusive
Filippo Berio Rustico Filippo Berio, packed in Massarosa (Lucca), Italy A 500ml unfiltered extra virgin olive oil UK supermarkets, for example Morrisons
Borrelli Rustico Borrelli Gourmet Foods Extra virgin olive oil in 1L and 3L sizes; labelled "Product of Italy", with ingredients given as "extra virgin olive oil (EU origin)" Borrelli's own online shop

The Google results for "rustico olive oil" in the US are dominated by the Asaro brand and H-E-B, so the rest of this review is about Il Rustico di Casa Asaro. If you are in the UK and holding a Filippo Berio bottle, the label-reading advice further down applies, but the producer facts do not.

Tall glass bottle of golden-green oil, dark glass bottle and plain metal tin on a rustic wooden shelf

Who Makes Rustico Olive Oil?

The brand's "Our Story" page says the Asaro family has farmed olive trees for generations in the Valle del Belice in south-western Sicily. It also says that in 2005 the CEO, Tommaso Asaro, moved the family farmland to what the page calls a modern organic approach. The same page claims that the family farms produce more Nocellara del Belice (Castelvetrano) olives than any other in the world. That is the brand's own claim, and we have no independent figure to check it against.

The Texas link is deliberate. The brand says Tommaso Asaro partnered with H-E-B to create Il Rustico di Casa Asaro® as a range "perfect for a Texas plate", and its where-to-buy page states that the products are found exclusively at H-E-B and carry H-E-B's "Primo Picks" designation. H-E-B's own feature page says the oil is exclusively bottled for H-E-B, and that the Asaro family marked its 100th harvest in 2016.

The producing company is Oleificio Asaro dal 1916. Its 2026 New York International Olive Oil Competition results list the same mill behind the Partanna, Paesanol and Frankies 457 labels. We have reviewed Partanna olive oil and Frankies olive oil separately. Rustico is best understood as the family's H-E-B label rather than a separate producer.

Wooden crate of large bright green olives beneath an ancient olive tree in a sunlit Sicilian grove

The Rustico Range at a Glance

The brand's product page, checked on 8 October 2026, lists five oils and a jar of olives. The table summarises the oils from the brand's own product pages.

Product Size Ingredients (as listed) Notes from the brand
Rustico Extra Virgin Unfiltered 33.8 fl oz (1 L) 100% extra virgin olive oil (unfiltered) The flagship; "grassy, herbal, buttery smoothness, slightly sweet finish"
Rustico Extra Virgin Unfiltered USDA Organic 25.4 fl oz (750 mL) 100% USDA Certified Organic extra virgin olive oil (unfiltered) Described as the certified organic version of the flagship
Rustico Sicilian Lemon 8.5 fl oz (250 mL) Olive oil, Sicilian lemons Made with partner producers
Rustico Calabrian Chili Not checked Not checked Made with partner producers
Rustico White Truffle Not checked Not checked Made with partner producers

Two details are worth noticing. First, the flavoured oils are not presented as estate oil: the brand says it "partnered with some of Italy's best producers" to make them. The lemon oil's ingredients read "Olive Oil, Sicilian Lemons", not "extra virgin olive oil". If grade matters to you, buy the plain unfiltered oil and add your own lemon. Our guide to lemon olive oil explains the difference between co-pressed and infused versions.

Second, the range also includes pitted green Castelvetrano olives. H-E-B's range feature also mentions an Olio Nuovo, described as "produced only once a year in limited quantities", so check the shelf for it in season.

Glass cruets of olive oil infused with lemon zest and dried red chillies beside a bowl of green olives

What "Unfiltered" Means for the Bottle You Buy

Unfiltered extra virgin olive oil is bottled without being passed through a filter, so it keeps tiny particles of olive fruit and moisture. These give it a slightly cloudy look and can settle as a soft sediment at the bottom of the bottle. Rustico's own ingredient line, "100% extra virgin olive oil (unfiltered)", places it squarely in this style, and sediment in a Rustico bottle is normal.

A fair objection is that unfiltered oil is not automatically better oil. The particles that give it a fuller taste also carry water and enzymes, which is why unfiltered oil is usually recommended for steady use rather than long storage. The brand's own storage advice is to keep it "in cool, dry place away from light and heat". The practical rule is simple: open it, use it, and do not store a one-litre bottle next to the stove. Our explainer on unfiltered vs filtered olive oil goes into the trade-off in more detail.

One honest gap: neither the brand's site nor H-E-B's listing publishes a harvest date, acidity, peroxide value or polyphenol figure for Rustico. "Pressed within hours of harvest" tells you about milling practice, not about how old the oil in a particular bottle is. If the label carries a harvest or best-before date, that is the number to check.

Clear glass bottle of cloudy unfiltered golden-green olive oil with settled sediment and a cork on dark wood

The Awards: What the Competition Record Shows

The brand states that Rustico Unfiltered won a Gold Medal at the New York International Olive Oil Competition (NYIOOC) in 2016, from among about 800 oils, and Silver awards in 2023, 2025 and 2026. H-E-B's range page repeats the 2016 Gold.

The 2026 result is independently on the record: the NYIOOC's own results coverage lists a Silver Award for Il Rustico di Casa Asaro, entered by Oleificio Asaro dal 1916, among nine awards for the mill that year. One small detail in that coverage is worth knowing. It lists the Partanna and Paesanol Regular oils as Nocellara del Belice monocultivars, and it lists Il Rustico di Casa Asaro as a blend. The Rustico product page does not name its olive varieties, so do not assume the bottle is pure Castelvetrano fruit just because the family is known for it.

As always with awards, a medal is a judgement on a sample from one harvest. Rustico's record — a Gold ten years ago and Silvers in recent years — reads best as evidence of a mill that keeps producing sound, well-judged oil, rather than proof that any bottle on a shelf today has itself won.


Rustico and Sidr & Stone: A Fair Comparison

Sidr & Stone also sells olive oil, so you should read this section knowing that we have a stake in it. The table sticks to what each producer publishes.

Dimension Il Rustico di Casa Asaro Sidr & Stone
Origin Asaro family farms, Valle del Belice, south-western Sicily Our own single-estate farm near Marrakech, Morocco
Style Unfiltered extra virgin; NYIOOC 2026 lists it as a blend Unfiltered extra virgin from one estate
Organic status USDA certified organic version available (750 mL) Grown naturally; not certified organic
Published figures None on the brand or H-E-B pages No published laboratory figure yet
Awards NYIOOC Gold (2016) and Silvers, per the brand; 2026 Silver confirmed in NYIOOC results None claimed
Where to buy H-E-B (Texas and heb.com) Online, direct from us; we ship globally

Rustico has the stronger public record on two counts, and we will not downplay either. It has a USDA certified organic version, and it has a run of NYIOOC awards. Our olive oil is grown naturally on our own farm but is. What we offer is a different origin and a narrower promise: one grove, one oil, cold-pressed.


How to Choose a Rustico Bottle (and Whether to)

If you shop at H-E-B, Rustico is easy to buy, and the plain unfiltered oil is the one the awards relate to. Choose the USDA Organic version if certification matters to you. Treat the flavoured oils as condiments rather than as extra virgin olive oil. Our look at H-E-B's olive oil shelf sets Rustico alongside the grocer's own labels and the other national brands it stocks.

Whichever Rustico you pick, check three things on the bottle: any harvest or best-before date, whether the bottle has been sitting under bright shop lights, and the size relative to how fast you cook. One litre of unfiltered oil is a lot for a small household. Our guide to choosing a quality olive oil covers dates, storage and labels in more depth.

If what draws you to Rustico is the Sicilian origin, our overview of Sicilian olive oil and our guide to Nocellara olives explain the cultivar and how its protected designations work. Our A–Z of olive oil brands places Rustico alongside other names.


Why Sidr & Stone

Rustico shows what a large Sicilian family mill can offer through a single retail partner. Sidr & Stone's olive oil comes from a different place, with a different set of verified facts:

  • Sidr & Stone's olive oil is single-estate: our own family-owned farm near Marrakech, Morocco, with every step controlled from tree to bottle and no blending across origins.
  • Sidr & Stone's olives are grown without pesticides, herbicides or chemical fertilisers.
  • Our olives are picked when the fruit is ready; the product page has this harvest's details.
  • Sidr & Stone's oil is cold-pressed.
  • Sidr & Stone's oil is unfiltered extra virgin and may show natural sediment.
  • Sidr & Stone's oil is 100% natural: one ingredient, no additives.
  • Sidr & Stone uses matte black glass that blocks out light.
  • Sidr & Stone has pledged 10% of its profits to charity.
  • Sidr & Stone ships globally.

We will not tell you our oil is better than Rustico — we have no award or laboratory figure to support that. What we will say is that it is single-estate Moroccan, grown naturally and cold-pressed.

Sidr & Stone olive oil bottle on terracotta tiles beside a dish of olive oil and rustic bread

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Rustico olive oil good?

Il Rustico di Casa Asaro has a respectable record: the brand reports a 2016 NYIOOC Gold, and the competition's 2026 results confirm a Silver Award. It is an unfiltered extra virgin oil from an established Sicilian mill. Neither the brand nor H-E-B publishes laboratory figures or a harvest date, so check the date on your bottle and use it promptly.

Who makes Rustico olive oil?

It is made by the Asaro family's company, Oleificio Asaro dal 1916, in the Valle del Belice in south-western Sicily, and the brand's US contact is United Olive Oil Import Corp. in New York. The same mill makes the Partanna and Frankies 457 olive oils.

Is Rustico olive oil really unfiltered?

Yes. The brand lists the flagship's ingredients as "100% extra virgin olive oil (unfiltered)", so a slight haze or a settled sediment is normal. Store it away from heat and light, and use it steadily once it is open.

Is Rustico olive oil made from Castelvetrano olives?

The Asaro family is known for Nocellara del Belice (Castelvetrano) olives, but the Rustico product page does not name the varieties. The 2026 NYIOOC results list Il Rustico di Casa Asaro as a blend, unlike the family's Partanna monocultivars, so do not assume it is pure Castelvetrano.

How does Rustico compare with Sidr & Stone?

Rustico offers a Sicilian unfiltered oil, a USDA certified organic version and a run of competition awards, sold through H-E-B. Sidr & Stone offers one single-estate Moroccan extra virgin olive oil, grown naturally, with no published laboratory figure. The fair choice is between origins and styles, not a proven quality gap.

Is Filippo Berio Rustico the same oil?

No. Filippo Berio Rustico is a 500ml unfiltered extra virgin olive oil from Filippo Berio, packed in Massarosa, Italy, and sold in UK supermarkets. Borrelli also sells a "Rustico" extra virgin olive oil. Neither is connected to the Asaro family's Il Rustico di Casa Asaro.

Where can I buy Rustico olive oil?

The brand says Il Rustico di Casa Asaro is found exclusively at H-E-B, in store and on heb.com for curbside or delivery. Third-party resellers sometimes list it online, so check the seller and the date on the bottle. Our own Marrakech oil is available to order directly from us.

Do you make medical claims about your oil?

No. We don't make medical claims about our oil. If you take medication, especially blood thinners such as warfarin, or are pregnant or breastfeeding, speak to your doctor first.


Final Thoughts

Rustico earns its following honestly. It is an unfiltered Sicilian extra virgin oil from a mill with more than a century of history and a public competition record, and it is easy to buy if you live near an H-E-B. The useful caveats are about the record, not the oil: it is a blend rather than a named single variety, there are no published harvest or laboratory figures, and the flavoured bottles are partner-made infusions. The other "Rustico" bottles on the market belong to other companies.

If you would like a Moroccan single-estate alternative, our Cold-Pressed Single-Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil - Marrakech (500ml) is available to order directly from us.

Sidr & Stone olive oil bottle with gold pourer beside tomato salad, bread and green olives at sunset

Our extra virgin olive oil comes from our own single-estate farm on the plains outside Marrakech, where we control every step from tree to bottle. The olives are grown naturally, with no pesticides, herbicides or chemical fertilisers.

Order Now: Sidr & Stone Cold-Pressed Single-Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil — Marrakech (500ml) →


Disclaimer: This article describes Il Rustico di Casa Asaro's product information, H-E-B's listings and published competition results as checked on 8 October 2026; specifications, certifications, awards and availability may change, and readers should check current sources. We don't make medical claims about our oil. For any health concern, consult a qualified medical professional. Comparisons are made in good faith and in fair terms. Sidr & Stone is not affiliated with or endorsed by the Asaro family, Oleificio Asaro dal 1916, United Olive Oil Import Corp., H-E-B, Filippo Berio, Borrelli or any retailer named.

Back to blog